Back to Recipes

Sugar Substitutes

Foodista
A guide for sweetener substitutions.
Intermediate
Sugar Substitutes
flickr user Liz Henry

Total Steps

13

Ingredients

12

Tools Needed

3

Ingredients

  • Sucanat
  • Fruitsource
  • maple syrup granules
  • date sugar
  • raw honey
  • 3-4 tablespoons flour(optional)
  • brown rice syrup
  • barley malt syrup
  • liquid maple syrup
  • blackstrap molasses
  • white refined sugar
  • brown sugar

Instructions

1

Step 1

Sucanat, Fruitsource, and Maple Syrup Granules are dry sweeteners that can substitute almost perfectly for granulated refined white sugar. These are often found in health food stores and co-ops, and some stores may special order or stock them if there is interest.

2

Step 2

SUCANAT: Evaporated whole cane juice. It has a similar color to brown sugar but is opaque and tastes richer. It retains maximum nutritional value. Use in like amounts when substituting for refined brown or white sugars. It costs about $2 per pound.

3

Step 3

FRUITSOURCE: A dry, yellowish-white sweetener made from evaporated rice syrup and white grape juice. It can be hard to find but substitutes well for white refined sugar, especially when color is important. It has a slightly fruity taste which may alter the end product. It is often used half and half with another sweetener, like Sucanat.

4

Step 4

MAPLE SYRUP GRANULES: Evaporated maple syrup. This rich-tasting, granulated dry sweetener is wonderful but expensive (over $8 per pound). Use in like amounts when substituting for refined brown or white sugars.

5

Step 5

DATE SUGAR: This sweetener is easier to find but still quite expensive.

6

Step 6

Date sugar is made of ground dates. Some recipes suggest dissolving it in liquid first, though this may not always be necessary.

7

Step 7

Date sugar is less frequently used due to its higher cost (around $5 per pound) compared to Sucanat.

8

Step 8

Raw honey can also be used, but in half the amount of dry white sugar. Adjust dry/wet ingredients to compensate. General rules for substitution are:

9

Step 9

For every 1 cup of white refined sugar, substitute 1/2 cup of raw honey. Decrease the liquid in the recipe by 1/4 cup. If there is no liquid to reduce, add 3-4 tablespoons of flour per half cup of honey used. Additionally, decrease oven temperature by 25 degrees Fahrenheit, as honey-sweetened goods brown faster.

10

Step 10

Honey-sweetened goods tend to have a longer shelf life compared to those sweetened with sucrose.

11

Step 11

Experimentation with honey is often necessary, as its taste can be overpowering initially. Different types of honey have varying flavor profiles. Honey can also alter the texture of recipes. For quick breads, dry sweeteners like Sucanat and Fruitsource are recommended over wet sweeteners.

12

Step 12

Most recipes, unless health-conscious, call for excessive sweetener. Consider reducing the sweetener and using slightly less liquid to compensate for the reduction in dry ingredients. Always take notes when experimenting with recipes.

13

Step 13

Brown rice syrup, barley malt syrup, liquid maple syrup, and blackstrap molasses are suitable for cookies, but not cakes or quick breads. Adjust by adding slightly less liquid or increasing dry ingredients. These are less sweet than honey, so use 2/3 to 3/4 of the amount of white or brown refined sugar. Wet sweeteners are also useful in recipes requiring a small amount, such as spaghetti sauce or yeast breads.

Tools & Equipment

measuring cups
measuring spoons
oven

Tags

Cookie Consent

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalized content, and analyze our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies. Learn more